The Problem of Values

A few years ago, I participated in the first month or so of discussions that much later became a book called Powered by Principle, by my friend and colleague, Amie Devero.  The book was built in part on the work we did with clients over a 5 year period.

Since then, however, I have started to realize how unreliable my value-radar has become.

For example, I was in a meeting with a client when they asked me why I always preferred to drink water.  We had a little back and forth on the topic, and I joked about possible imaginary reasons when it struck me that their guesses were all incorrect because no-one in the group was a runner.

(More often than not, I drink a lot of water in order to recover from early morning exercise, in the hope of recovering fully for the following day’s workout.)

They were guessing incorrectly, because they had no idea what “value” was driving my drinking behaviours. Also, while there was no dispute that I was in fact drinking water, there were any number of possible values that were driving my actions.

How then could we even talk about values?  Were they anything else than a convenient construct that we could neither verify nor validate?  I would admit that I could change my mind on the matter, and give different answers about underlying values driving my drinking depending on my mood.

In this sense, I wholeheartedly disagree with the author of the article: “Why Corporate Culture is a Myth” who says:

The values of a group might be honorable — or not. Unlike the mushier name culture, with its connotation of a cozy melting pot or a delightfully harmonious salad bowl, values includes more than what is outwardly professed, endlessly parroted and tritely canonized on T-shirts and coffee mugs. It also encompasses what is implicit, often deliberately buried and denied. People may talk your ear off about their culture, but values can be seen in real-time … as evidenced by real actions.
In my work as a recruiter, it helps me to think of companies as big, messy families with varying degrees of dysfunction … despite the many talents and productive output of its members. In this context, the challenge becomes less about matching cultures than about elevating values — bearing in mind, of course, how resistant systems are to anything other than mild, incremental change.

If, as the author states, values encompass what is implicit, often deliberately buried and denied, then how can we possibly know what we are even talking about?  He goes on to say that values can be seen in real-time… as evidenced by real actions.

Huh?

That makes no sense to me.  Actions can be seen in real time.  Values can’t.  The best that we humans can muster are judgements about the actions we observe.

To turn them into values, or even “true values” is a huge step to make that probably isn’t worth making in a corporate context.  Maybe it’s better for us to focus on behaviours than values, and to be honest about the fact that we are always imputing values on others behaviours.  Unfortunately, this often take us down the road of condemning other people and actions that we dislike.

It’s at this point that companies launch Values programs… a nebulous exercise that has more to do with our prejudices than what is happening in the real world.

No Such Thing as Corporate Culture?

The following article claims that’s there’s no such thing as corporate culture: Why Corporate Culture is a Myth.

I’d love to hear what you think, because I was more convinced than ever that it’s real as described by the following attributes listed in the article:

  1. Creation story (like in the Bible)
  2. Creed (as in “this is the Cubs’ year”)
  3. Rituals (banging drums in the sweat lodge)
  4. Icons (dazzling the senses, from coffee to doughnuts)
  5. Sacred words (”grande decaf latte, please”)
  6. Pagans (those who refuse to drink the Kool-Aid)
  7. Fearless Leader (from Buddha to Welch)

Seems like a good descriptor of the elements of a corporate culture, and could make for some interesting comparisons between cultures.

But read the article and tell me what YOU think…

Caribbean Culture Post

Someone over at the ReggaeBoyz discussion forum posted up an article from my blog (to my surprise) that has been generating a great deal of discussion.

The original article entitled “Differences in Culture Between Caribbean Countries”  is all of 5 years old, and can be found at this link.

I welcome any serious comments or questions — ( but “fool-fool-foolishness” will simply be marked as spam.)

I’m amazed that it was written in 2005, as it seems quite applicable even today.

Co-Hosting on BusinessuiteToday

bess fmThe last month has been a hectic one, and I have some good news to report.   I now have the pleasure of co-hosting a fairly new radio program here in Jamaica, on BESS FM – 100.1.

It’s a business program, and I got off the mark on February 1st with a focus on the topic of the acquisition of Air Jamaica by Caribbean Airlines.

I’ll be working for a while with Aldo Owen, who is working alongside me while I develop some of the skills needed to be a good radio host.

Before I came on the station, I did do a few guest appearances.

Here is an 11 minute recording of a radio interview I did in late 2009 on the topic of corporate culture.

Video: Intolerance in the Caribbean Workplace

In October 2008, I completed an issue of FirstCuts (#27) that pointed to the fact that intolerance in the Caribbean workplace comes at a very high price.

That post came on the heels of comments made by Prime Minister Bruce Golding of Jamaica that gays would not be allowed to join his cabinet.

A policeman, and therefore a member of the civil service, recently came out of the closet, and in declaring that he is gay, shared his experience at the risk of facing a severe backlash.

What should an executive, HR director or board member do if this were a private company?

Here is the link to my original FirstCuts article: https://blog.fwconsulting.com/2008/09/the-not-so-diverse-caribbean-workplace/

FirstCuts31 – Accepting the Plantation

The latest issue of FirstCuts is now available in a very new format.

Gone are my struggles with ASCII files that Microsoft Outlook would mangle into an unrecognizable melange.

Now, there’s a magazine-like interface that allows a user to read through the ezine much as they would a paper periodical.

Receiving FirstCuts on a regular basis is easy – -simply send email to firstcuts@aweber.com and click on the link in the confirmation email.

In the meantime, click on the icon below to be taken to this month’s issue of FirstCuts.  The audio version can be heard by clicking here — Podcast of FirstCuts31

Here is a short excerpt.  Also, I welcome any comments you may have here on the blog.

—————————–

Accepting the Plantation

One of the gifts that expats bring to a job in our region is a view of what it would be like to work in an environment that’s free of the tragic history that plagues the Caribbean workplace.

Expats remind those of us who work in the region that our workplace is a unique one that’s been unable to escape its past. It’s uniqueness comes from the fact that it’s the only workplace in the world that remains staffed by a majority of citizens whose ancestors were brought to the region as slaves or indentured servants.

—————————–

To continue reading, click on the icon below.

Jack Welch at Recent B’dos Conference

Recently, Jack Welch, Dennis O’Brien of Digicel and Arthur Lok Jak of Neal and Massy presented at the Caribbean International Leadership Summit in Barbados.

What is remarkable is that there were over 200 attendees to the two day event, each paying some US$1800 per person.

This clearly shows me that there is an appetite for this kind of event here in the region, and that CEOs are willing to invest the time and money to hear top quality information.

It is also great to see that the audios and PDF files from the top presentations are available for download from the website.

Kudos to those who had the vision to bring this together, and I am only sorry that I missed it.

Steve Jobs Speech at Stanford

I write a lot about doing what one loves to do.

I am fortunate to say that I wake up each morning being able to say this, and apparently so does Steve Jobs: