When the Answer Is “Never”: Why Countries With Few Options Need One Strategy

I asked an AI a simple question about my country, and it answered with one word: “never.”

The question was how many years Jamaica, a small Caribbean island economy, would need to reach the average income per person of its regional neighbours. A minute earlier, I had run the same test on a different problem. How long would it take the United States to match China’s high-speed rail network? At the current pace of expansion, that answer was also “never.”

Jamaica’s answer came in two parts. At 3 percent annual growth, the gap closes in more than four decades. At the country’s actual rate over the past three decades, about 0.39 percent a year, it does not close at all. The gap widens every year.

An AI answer is a rough check, not a forecast. I treat it as a prompt to examine the inputs. The inputs turn out to be worth examining.

If you lead a business, advise a government or invest in a small, open economy, Jamaica is a useful case. Its numbers are clear, its strategy question is clear, and the lessons travel.

Where the gap comes from

Sixty-six years ago, Jamaica stood roughly level with Barbados, the Bahamas and Trinidad and Tobago. Today its income per person sits near US$8,000, while those three range from roughly US$18,500 to US$40,000. Workers produce about US$8.81 of output per hour, against roughly US$20.50 across the region.

The tax base tells the same story. In 2025, economist Damien King wrote that fewer than 15 percent of employed Jamaicans effectively carry the weight of income tax. A small group underwrites everyone else, which points to low earnings for most workers.

The usual diagnosis is effort. It is a natural guess, and it aims at the wrong level of the problem.

Effort or system

Most managers know the standard fix for low productivity. Ask people to work harder, learn more skills or use better technology. Those are productivity problems, and they respond to training, incentives and tools.

A productivity-system problem sits one level higher. The environment around people, firms and institutions keeps converting their resources into too little economic value, whatever effort they supply. Think of the rail comparison. No amount of optimism or willpower gives the United States the railway density of China, because the gap lives in the structure of the system: decades of accumulated decisions, infrastructure and institutions.

Jamaica’s clearest sign of a system problem is education. By the figures I use here, its schools turn fewer than 80 percent of incoming five-year-olds into functionally literate adults, well below the regional average. Every employer downstream inherits that result.

One chain of cause and effect

In the commentary I follow, economists and business leaders in Jamaica point in the same direction. Start at an endpoint such as Caribbean-average income per person by 2050, then work backwards from that target with two questions. What is the primary obstacle to that result? What is the main challenge behind that obstacle?

The answer they converge on is that the primary obstacle is productivity, and the main challenge behind productivity is functional literacy. That gives you a chain with three links: literacy, then productivity, then growth. I call it Jamaica’s strategic trifecta.

My own reasoning for the first link is simple. A worker who can read a contract, a safety manual or a spreadsheet can learn the next skill. One who cannot is capped from the start.

The chain explains the lopsided tax base. It also explains why short-term fixes keep disappointing: outsourced call centres, apparel assembly zones and all-inclusive tourism. These tend to rely on low-cost workers, so they add less to the wider economy than a more skilled workforce would.

How steep the climb is

Reaching the Caribbean average by 2050 would take roughly 4.5 percent growth a year. That is about eleven times the 0.39 percent Jamaica has managed. The calculation assumes the regional average keeps growing at about 1.5 percent a year, so a faster-growing region raises the bar.

Delay raises the price faster than most people expect. At the current trend the gap keeps widening while the deadline draws closer. Wait five years and the required rate rises to about 5.5 percent. Wait ten and it reaches about 7.5 percent. Every year of waiting shortens the time to climb and lengthens the distance.

Why few options make strategy essential

A wealthy country with many options can afford to drift. It can absorb a bad decade, borrow, or switch industries. A small economy with few options has little slack.

Strategy is the discipline of choosing what to leave out. A country with many options can fund many bets. A country with few must pick, and it must pick right the first time.

Jamaica faces further climate events whose recovery costs compete directly with the investment needed to grow. A windfall of oil, gas or gold would be luck, and luck is a poor foundation for a plan. The fewer options a country has, the more it needs one well-understood strategy, because there is no budget for funding the wrong one first.

Jamaica has shown it can do this. In the mid-2010s, the country accepted that continual fiscal instability was unacceptable, and a broad consensus formed. That decision paid off in the fiscal stability the country has today. Pressure forced the choice, and the choice worked. The task now is to bring the same discipline to growth.

Five substitutes that feel like strategy

If you work in a stalled economy, you will recognise these. Each one feels like progress and avoids the strategy:

– Waiting for a rescuer, such as a new leader, a donor or a megaproject. Someone else’s plan arrives with someone else’s priorities.

– Doing many things, in plans with dozens of priorities. Attention spreads thin and nothing gets enough.

– Fixing an adjacent problem such as crime, exchange rates, roads or technology. Each is worthwhile on its own, and none of them addresses the chain.

– Growing what already works, such as tourism, remittances or outsourcing. Strengths help, and they do not replace a strategy.

– Leaving, or hoping that more positive thinking will do the job. Individual effort and optimism cannot repair a system.

A plan built backwards from the future

Jamaica already has a national plan, Vision 2030, written in 2009 with the goal of reaching developed-country status by 2030. Seventeen years in, with four to go, the country is further from it than ever. A successor national plan is under development.

That successor should be the venue for five steps:

1. Agreeing that past national strategy-making has produced stagnant results, including the current plan.

2. Working out how the trifecta operates: literacy, then productivity, then growth.

3. Setting a target year for the successor plan, such as 2050.

4. Defining the most important results for that year, and become willing to subordinate other valuable outcomes.

5. Crafting a strategy that connects 2050 back to today, with short-, mid- and long-term projects.

The order matters. Agreement comes first, because a plan built on a disputed diagnosis will not survive the next change of leadership.

One more obstacle

Every society has habits that favour the immediate over the deferred, such as spending on today’s comfort when the payoff arrives a decade later. Jamaica has its own version, and it shows up in public agencies, private firms and community groups alike.

Jamaica has already steered around it once, when fiscal stability demanded it. That episode shows the habit can be managed when the stakes are clear.

Your next move

At its current pace and strategy, Jamaica may never catch the Caribbean. The United States may never match China’s rail network at its current pace either. Both gaps trace back to choices people made, which means different choices can narrow them.

If you lead, invest in or advise a small economy with few options, take three questions to your next board or cabinet meeting:

– What chain of cause and effect do we believe ends at growth?

– What would we have to leave out if we backed one strategy?

– Who owns that strategy, and by when will we agree on it?

Then check whether your answers look anything like literacy, then productivity, then growth.

———————-

This article is based on my Jamaica Gleaner column. This version is AI generated.

P.S. Put the ideas to work

Paste any of these prompts into an AI assistant such as ChatGPT or Claude and replace the brackets with your own details. Each prompt asks the assistant to question you, so your answers drive the result. Treat the output as a sparring partner’s view, and check any facts yourself.

1. Diagnose effort or system

Act as a sceptical strategy adviser. I want to understand why [my country / company / team] keeps underperforming at [specific result]. Ask me one question at a time to find out whether this is a productivity problem (effort, skills, tools) or a productivity-system problem (an environment that turns resources into too little value). After six questions, tell me which it looks like, what evidence supports that view and what evidence would change your mind. Do not invent facts.

2. Build your own chain

I want to reach [specific result] by [target year]. Work backwards with me. Ask what the primary obstacle to that result is, then what the main challenge behind that obstacle is. Write the answer as a chain of three links: [link 1], then [link 2], then [link 3]. For each link, challenge the cause-and-effect claim, tell me what evidence I would need and suggest one way to test it. Do not assume anything I have not told you.

3. Run the catch-up math

Help me calculate how long it takes to close a gap. My level today is [X] and the benchmark is [Y], both measured the same way in [currency, real or nominal terms]. My recent annual growth is [A] percent and the benchmark grows at [B] percent. Show the formula and each step. Tell me how many years it takes to close the gap at current rates, what annual growth I need to close it by [target year], and what that rate becomes if I wait five years and ten years. List every assumption and flag any input that mixes real and nominal figures.

4. Audit your substitutes

Here are the initiatives my organisation or country is pursuing: [list]. Sort each one into one of five substitutes for strategy: waiting for a rescuer, doing many things, fixing an adjacent problem, growing existing strengths, or leaving and positive thinking. Mark any that address the root-cause chain directly. Then ask me which one I would drop if we could back only one strategy, and test my answer.

5. Test your options and your blind spot

I lead or advise [organisation / country] and we have few real options. Ask me to list the options we believe we have, then challenge which ones are real. Help me name one habit in our culture that favours the immediate over the deferred, and one time we overcame a similar pressure, such as a past reform. Ask what made that earlier success possible and how we could recreate those conditions for [current challenge]. End with one sentence I could say to my board